We were delighted to join with Blackstone Chambers for a panel discussion on the constitutional protection of property rights in public and private law litigation.

Insights on this interesting and important topic were shared from the front lines of litigation in both Hong Kong (

) and London (Tom Weisselberg KC and Monica Carss-Frisk KC).

A big thank you to all who attended the event and contributed to the lively discussion.

Beijing Renji Real Estate Development Group Co., Ltd v Zhu

 Min [2024] HKCA 878, the Court of Appeal examined the novel question of whether there was a “choice of Mainland court agreement” under the Mainland Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Ordinance (Cap 597) ("

") if the choice of Mainland court clause was not expressly found in the contract but applicable only by operation of Mainland statutory law.

The Plaintiff entered into a Partnership Agreement with Hainan Zhongtou. The Defendant (director of Hainan Zhongtou) and Hangzhou Cybernaut issued the Guarantee in favour of the Plaintiff to guarantee Hainan Zhongtou’s obligation under the Partnership Agreement. Clause 90 of the Partnership Agreement was a choice of Mainland courts clause, but the Guarantee does not contain such a clause.

The Plaintiff commenced proceedings in Beijing. In a judgment by the Beijing Higher People’s Court (the “

”), Hainan Zhongtou, the Defendant, and Hangzhou Cybernaut were held liable to the Plaintiff for over RMB 200 billion.

The Plaintiff then applied to register the BHPC Judgment in Hong Kong under the MJREO. G Lam JA (sitting as an additional judge of the Court of First Instance) set aside the registration order on the ground that there was no “choice of Mainland court agreement” in the Guarantee.

The Court of Appeal dismissed the Plaintiff’s appeal for the following reasons:

, instructed by Jones Day, acted for the Defendant.

Members

Recruitment

Latest News

Court of Appeal Considers The Meaning of “Choice of Mainland Court Agreement” under The Mainland Judgments (Reciprocal Enforcement) Ordinance

Recent Judgments

Latest Events

Cash, Cars and Chickens: Constitutional Property Rights

PRACTICE AREAS

About

Members

Recruitment

What’s New